The ancient philosopher Socrates has a famous statement that says, “The unexamined life is not worth living” and for me, that notion has been particularly present in my life in these last 6 years of journeying through 2 seminary degrees. Going through seminary for me has not just been or even primarily been about gathering new information. Yes, I have learned an awful lot and feel more prepared to educate others about what I’ve learned. However, my seminary journey has been most profoundly transformational for me because it has caused me in so many ways to look at who I am. Who is this person, Shane, who feels he is called to be a pastor, a counselor, a theologian? I must say that I didn’t come to Seminary originally thinking I would be asked or even forced to look at myself…I came to learn about ‘information’, i.e., supposedly abstract knowledge taught to me by wise and learned individuals. Yet, if seminary only would have done this for me, I know I would not be as prepared to go out and be a minister and counselor, even a theologian, as I feel I am now. In many ways, I have become the most important book I’ve learned to read during these past 6 years. For some, what I’m saying might sound confusing, wrong, or just odd; for others, it may make perfect and normal sense. I guess what I’ve learned is that there are reasons we all, as humans beings, choose to do what we do, whether it is follow a vocation, career, choose to get married, have kids, live here or there, do this or that, and as a result, the question of ‘why’ we do this or that is important. Why did I come to seminary? What I’ve learned is that my motives were mixed. I came to seminary to learn about God and learn how to serve him in the world (positive motives?); I also came to seminary to learn how to become a spiritual hero, rescuer, and teacher (negative motives?). Basically I’ve learned that my motives are almost always mixed in life, work, and even play. I used to see things so black and white, but now the world, and myself included, seem so much more gray. The world is not a simple place, God is not a simple being (if He is a ‘being’ as I consider that at all), and I am not a simple person. The world is complex, God is complex, and I am complex. I have ‘good’ and ‘bad’ sides; the question is, can I embrace both sides of myself or not? If I can, why can I? If I cannot, why can’t I? I’ve learned in these 6 years that pretending I don’t have a ‘bad’ side or sides to me causes a lot of trauma and damage to me and to others. I’ve been taught and trained in this world how to ’split’ myself; be good here and hide my badness so that I will be accepted. As a result, I get fearful when the thought arises I may have said or done something that hurt another because now they may not like this me that I have presented to them…as a result, I may be rejected, neglected, and unloved. So I do my best to present the most acceptable version of me that can be presented and hope (with fingers crossed) that whoever I am with (I can put on many different masks to fit different situations) will find this mask and act acceptable. However, by doing this I keep people from seeing who I truly am, the true me. Though I have been trained to believe I am a sinner, I have been taught, unspokenly, to reject that outright by pretending I don’t have a dark side that occasionally will cause harm to myself or others. So, I feel caught, trapped; can I be a sinner or can’t I be one? Or, perhaps I am both a sinner and a saint? Perhaps I am loved by God as a sinner and saint? Perhaps my sins, i.e., the things I say and do and am that break relationship with others and God, can teach me things about myself. Perhaps I can learn from the times I commit sins and see how they hurt me, others, and my well-being in the world. Perhaps, instead of hiding from them, I can bring them into the light, as John says in his letter, and trust God in all of God’s graciousness to embrace the complex good and bad me.
All of this presupposes that I have the courage to face myself…me…Shane, the sinner and saint. The child of God who can at one moment do or say wonderfully loving things and in the next moment, say or do amazingly foolish or hurtful things. Can I face the fact that I am not God, not perfect, not always right? Along with this however, can I face the fact that I am created in God’s image as a human and as a result, good, true, and beautiful? Can I live with the complexity of this arrangement? For most of my life, I have felt that I am either or, either good or bad…I haven’t felt I could somehow be both and still just be. Is it possible, however, that I could see myself, Shane, as a sinner and saint whom God loves not because of primarily what I do, but rather because I am His. Perhaps if I learned this about myself and my life, I could begin to learn to love and embrace others this way, as sinners and saints so that when they do something good I could be thankful but when they do something hurtful, I could seek to understand because I know they are both sinners and saints like me and as a result, not turn away from them but stay close to them, wanting to learn about them and their hurts, faults, frailties just as I am seeking to keep learning about my own. Perhaps this is what Jesus did and offered in his life and ministry and why he drew people to him so powerfully. Perhaps he knew himself so well and sought to know others so well that people just felt so embraced in the light of his presence and acceptance.
All this to say, though my seminary journey is nearing its end, my journey of learning about myself, God, this world, and others will not end. I have fallen in love with the journey of learning and it will not let go of me because I will not let go of it. God has grasped me and this journey I am on of discovering myself and how I can be His for the world and for myself keeps pulling me forward in new, beautiful, and mysterious ways that make this life so wonderful and precious. It has been a scary thing to learn about myself, to bring out the parts that I didn’t want to see or acknowledge, and yet, because of this part of my training, I feel I can be for myself, for others, and most importantly for God, what he would most prefer me to be…myself. As a famous rabbi once said, “When I get to heaven, God will not ask me why I was not Abraham, Moses, or David, he will ask me, why was I not” Shane? To be able to be myself though, I must learn about who I am and this is why I think Socrates statement is so wise for me and for all…to learn about ourselves so we can truly begin to learn about others and thus be ourselves truly with others.